Which Vortex Tube is Right for You?

EXAIR’s Vortex Tubes are a great product for many cooling applications. When supplied with a clean and moisture-free source of compressed air, they will generate two streams of airflow, one hot and one cold. They are a low-cost and reliable solution, capable of producing temperatures ranging from -50°F to +260°F. We have flow rates from 1scfm to 150scfm, producing refrigeration over 10,000btu/hr.

With this wide range of performance possible, it may be a bit daunting trying to select the right model of Vortex Tube. In this blog I am going to explain the differences between the two different series that we offer: 32XX and 34XX, and why you would want to choose one over the other.

The difference between the two model types comes down to the Cold Fraction, which is determined by where the Control Valve is positioned. When you open the Control Valve (by turning it counterclockwise, as shown by the blue arrow in the photo to the right), it decreases the Cold Fraction, which leads to a reduced flow and a significant drop in temperature in the cold air discharge. Conversely, closing the Control Valve (by turning it clockwise, indicated by the red arrow) boosts the cold air flow, but causes a smaller temperature drop. This ability to adjust is crucial for the Vortex Tube’s flexibility.

You can set the Cold Fraction as low as 20%, which means that a small portion (20% to be precise) of the supply air is sent to the cold end, resulting in a significant temperature drop. On the flip side, you can crank it up to 80%, meaning that most of the supply air heads to the cold end, but the temperature drop won’t be as drastic. Our 34XX Series Vortex Tubes are designed for Cold Fractions between 20-50%, while the 32XX Series caters to 50-80% Cold Fractions.

So how do you select the right model for you? To determine this, you need to know what temperature and flow will best serve your application. For most situations, the ~20°F produced by an 80% cold fraction is sufficiently cold. At this cold fraction, you will get the most flow (80% of the inlet supplied). Applications like welding or brazing benefit from higher flows. When your starting temperature is hundreds of degrees Fahrenheit, there is little difference in blowing -20°F air vs +20°F. What you need is more volume to strip away the heat as quickly as possible. In this instance, a 32XX series is the way to go.

If you need lower flow, or to achieve extremely cold temperatures, then the 34XX series would be the best choice. A chocolate maker took advantage of the lower flow rates offered by this type of Vortex Tube as they didn’t want the airflow to disturb the surface of the chocolate as it cooled, affecting the finish. The greater temperature drop allowed for rapid cooling without reducing quality.

Whatever your cooling application, our Vortex Tubes will likely be able to help. If you would like to discuss it, please give us a call!

Al Wooffitt
Application Engineer

Send me an Email
Find us on the Web
Like us on Facebook
Twitter: @EXAIR_AW

Vortex Tube Theory

Vortex Tube theory is one of the more interesting accidental inventions of the 20th Century…splitting a flow of air into two streams: one hot, and one cold.  Georges Ranque happened upon the phenomenon in the 1930s. He patented it in 1933, but it wasn’t commercially viable at the time. In the 1940s, it caught the interest of German physicist Rudolph Hilsch, who “tweaked” Ranque’s design and published a widely read paper on it in 1947. Over the next few decades, the use of compressed air became more prevalent in a wide range of industries, eventually becoming the “4th utility” that it’s known as today. With that increase in use came improvements in air compressor design & function – improvements that finally bestowed long-awaited commercial viability on the Vortex Tube.

From Ranque’s curious observation of a previously unknown physical phenomenon, to mass production & worldwide use, the Vortex Tube is truly a marvel of 20th Century technological advances.

So, how does it work? Ranque’s patent and Hilsch’s paper both detail what it is and what it does, but to this day, nobody’s been able to offer any 100% scientific proof as to HOW it does what it does. The commonly accepted explanation involves a proven scientific principle called conservation of angular momentum. That’s a mouthful, so let’s break it down:

Momentum is a physical property of matter, defined by its mass and velocity…and it depends on both. Something with more mass will have more momentum than something with less mass, if their velocities are the same. And something moving at a higher velocity will have more momentum than something that’s moving slower, as long as their masses are the same. Unless otherwise specified, “momentum” is usually considered to be linear – the matter is moving in one direction.

Angular momentum is also defined by mass and velocity, but its value is also affected by rotational inertia, which is determined by the distribution of its mass around the center point of its rotation. If an object moving at a certain velocity is forced closer to its rotational center point, it has to speed up to maintain (or conserve) angular momentum. Physics really, really, (really) wants to make that happen, according to the laws of conservation of matter & energy. And physics ALWAYS obeys the law…which forces us to as well.

Consider figure skaters doing those dizzying moves where they spin on the ice on one skate. If the skater spins with their arms straight out and then brings their arms in, close to their body, they begin to spin faster. The skater’s mass doesn’t change, but their mass distribution around the rotational center point does…so physics gets its way by increasing the velocity. Therefore, energy (angular momentum, in this case) is conserved. It’s impressive how easy some of them make it look:

In a Vortex Tube, the airflow is discharged tangentially into the tube, making it spin inside the inner wall of the tube at a specific velocity. When it reaches the end of the tube, it’s forced to change directions and continue spinning inside that outer spinning flow, but in the opposite direction. Unlike our figure skater in the example above, though, its velocity doesn’t change. Something has to, though, because physics ALWAYS gets its way. Since the energy of its angular momentum HAS to be conserved, that energy gets converted into heat, which transfers from the outer spinning flow and exits the vortex tube’s “hot” end. When it does so, the temperature of the remaining, inner spinning air flow goes down.

Just a few examples of how EXAIR Vortex Tubes are used in industry.

That’s our story, anyway, and we’re sticking to it. In any case, it works, and it works quite well. If you’d like to find out more, give me a call.

Russ Bowman, CCASS

Application Engineer
Visit us on the Web
Follow me on Twitter
Like us on Facebook

Video Blog: The Effects of Back Pressure On A Vortex Tube

The video below is one that I have explained to customers countless times over my tenure here at EXAIR. Vortex Tubes are most efficient when discharging the cold and hot air streams into atmospheric conditions. This video is my attempt to showcase just how much it will affect your performance when a restriction on the discharge cannot be avoided.

If you would like to discuss Vortex Tubes and their feasibility in your application, feel free to contact an Application Engineer today!

Brian Farno, MBA – CCASS Application Engineer

BrianFarno@EXAIR.com
@EXAIR_BF

Clerk Maxwell: The Man, the Myth, the Demon

Thermodynamics is a branch of physics that focuses on heat and energy. It studies how these forms of energy move and change within a system. An isolated system is a key concept in thermodynamics; it is a space that does not interact with anything outside of it. This means that no heat or energy can enter or leave a system. Understanding these principles helps scientists and engineers design better machines and improve energy efficiency.

The unique physical phenomenon of the Vortex Tube principle generates cold air instantly, and for as long – or short – a time as needed.

Maxwell’s demon is a thought experiment created by the mathematician James Clerk Maxwell. This imaginary being has the ability to see fast and slow-moving molecules in a gas. By sorting these molecules, the demon could supposedly create a situation where one side of the container is hot, and the other side is cold, without using energy. This idea challenges the second law of thermodynamics, which states that systems tend to move towards disorder. Maxwell’s demon shows that there are limits to our understanding of energy and order in the universe.

How a Vortex Tube Works

Maxwell’s demon is a molecule-sized trapdoor that separates a box of gas into two sides. The demon observes molecules and only allows fast-moving molecules to pass through to one side, and only slow-moving molecules to pass through to the other side. This would cause the temperature inside the container to increase without any work being applied, which would violate the second law of thermodynamics.

The cold air from the Vortex Tube (dark blue arrow) is aimed directly at the inlet plenum of the Air Amplifier. As it draws in environmental air (at ambient temperature, pale curved arrows), the Air Amplifier discharges cool air (light blue arrow) at the desired temperature.

The Vortex Tube by EXAIR is a product that demonstrates this theory to its fullest extent. Using an ordinary supply of compressed air as a power source, Vortex Tubes create two streams of air, one hot and one cold, with no moving parts. Vortex Tubes offer a temperature range between -50F to +260F, with flow rates ranging from 1 to 150 SCFM. EXIAR Vortex Tubes are constructed of stainless steel, which offers resistance to corrosion and oxidation, and will provide years of reliable, maintenance-free operation.

If you would like to discuss the Vortex Tube, please do not hesitate to contact an Application Engineer. We are always happy to help!

Jason Kirby
Application Engineer
Email: jasonkirby@exair.com
Twitter: @EXAIR_jk