How Do Membrane Dryers Work?

Water and water vapor can cause big problems in a compressed air system. That’s why compressed air dryers are a critical component of those systems. There are a few different types, and they all have their pros and cons. My colleague Jordan Shouse summed up the selection process pretty succinctly in a past blog: Compressed Air Dryers : What are they Good For? I particularly enjoyed his reference to Edwin Starr’s famous protest song, War (What Is It Good For?)

While they are all indeed “good for (as Jordan said) absolutely A LOT”, I wanted to take (another) deeper dive into one particular type. Membrane dryers are among the newer types of compressed air dryers. As the name suggests, they use a semi-permeable membrane whose structure allows molecules of certain fluids to pass through faster than others, thereby separating those certain fluids from the primary volume. Membrane separation technology is commonly used in:

  • Water purification and desalination (removal of particulates and salts)
  • Nitrogen separation (removal of oxygen and other trace gases)
  • Removing moisture from compressed air (removal of water vapor)

A membrane dryer is made of a cylinder containing very small polymer tubes that have a special coating inside. This coating allows the above-mentioned water & water vapor to pass through more readily than the nitrogen, oxygen, and other trace gases found in the atmospheric air that the compressor has drawn in.

As compressed air enters the cylinder, it’s directed through the polymer tubes, which allow water (but not air) to pass through their walls due to the difference in partial pressure between the gases (e.g., compressed air & water vapor) on the inside, & outside, of the tubes. Air flow, traveling in the opposite direction outside the tubes, sweeps the water out. The higher the sweep air flow rate, the lower the dew point of the compressed air out.

The advantages of membrane dryers are:

  • No moving parts to wear or break.
  • No electricity required.
  • Easy to install.
  • Unaffected by environmental contamination.
  • Compact design.

While environmental contamination isn’t a concern, they are very sensitive to internal contamination, like oil & oil vapor. Membrane dryers are commonly supplied with coalescing filters to minimize any issues there.

One disadvantage (kind of) is their limited flow capacity: the highest capacity membrane dryers are capable of passing around 200 SCFM, meaning they can only be used in small-to-mid-sized systems. I said “kind of” above because, if a certain part of the compressed air system requires a different level of dry air than the rest of the plant, membrane dryers are an inexpensive and easy way to provide that. That’s “kind of” an advantage, in that situation, actually.

Another disadvantage (kind of) is the amount of purge air they lose. Remember, membrane technology means certain fluids will pass through faster & more readily – but not exclusively – so they’re going to lose some of that brand new compressed air along with the water vapor. And the lower you want the dew point to be, the more purge air will be lost. However, the purge air loss is minimal when they’re discharging air dried to a dew point in the 40°F range, and that’s perfectly acceptable in many industrial compressed air systems.

I want to help you get the most out of your compressed air system, so when you think of compressed air, think EXAIR! If you’ve got questions, we’re here to help. Give me a call.

Russ Bowman, CCASS

Application Engineer
Visit us on the Web
Follow me on Twitter
Like us on Facebook

Dryers On A New Level – Deliquescent Level Even.

Today I want to discuss dryers and not the type that I have repaired many times due to having three kids in my house. Speaking of which, the amount of hair that gets trapped within a dryer is one of the things my nightmares are made from. You’d think we have a Yeti living in our home. While the picture below is of our first dryer and washer, that platform has been repurposed into a workbench and the metals have all been recycled back into something else now. That’s not what we are here to talk about. Instead, we are going to discuss deliquescent dryers.

Deliquescent dryers can sometimes be confusing. Some compressed air dryer vendors use the terms deliquescent and desiccant synonymously, as if they were interchangeable in describing their equipment. Deliquescent dryers are not complex drying systems and are most commonly found in the petrochemical industry.

Deliquescent Dryer

Unlike any other dryer, a deliquescent dryer is also used to reduce or remove moisture before it turns to liquid water. These dryers can be installed indoors, outdoors, offshore, or in any remote location. They do not require electricity for operational purposes or have any moving parts, making them easy to maintain and economically more efficient. In a deliquescent dryer, moist air (gas) passes over a layer of deliquescent tablets that absorb moisture. The pressure dew point lowers as the tablets slowly dissolve, the condensation falls into the drain area, and the drier air flows through the outlet into the piping system.

The best deliquescent materials are salts due to their strong attraction to moisture. Deliquescent desiccants (drying tablets) are formulated from calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, potassium chloride, and lithium chloride. Not all deliquescent desiccants are equal. The final formulation and properties of the desiccant can significantly impact the design of a dryer tank. That is, the surface of the desiccant chemical, often beads or pellets, will liquefy, and the resulting liquid will flow to the bottom of the vessel. There is either a drain (manual or auto) at the base of the deliquescent dryer which is used to expel the collected fluid.

Some factors that will affect the consumption of the desiccant are the type of adsorbent, type of adsorbate, the size of the adsorbent bead or pellet, the concentration of the adsorbate in the compressed air stream, and the temperature of that air stream.

You will want to have a water trap, also known as a general-purpose compressed air filter, plumbed in line just upstream from the deliquescent dryer. Otherwise, any liquid water flowing with the compressed air into the air dryer will make short work of the desiccant chemical, requiring a more frequent—and expensive—recharge.

Compressing air generates heat. That hot, moist compressed air will consume the desiccant chemical in the deliquescent dryer much more quickly. The best practice is to ensure the airflow to the dryer is as cool as possible, with a long airline and a dwell tank before the deliquescent dryer, to allow the air to cool and have water saturate out naturally.

A deliquescent dryer can be expected to reduce the compressed air dew point by 20 – 30 deg. F, or so. The degree of drying depends how saturated the airflow is going in and on the type of deliquescent chemical used.

Unlike other forms of compressed air dryers, a deliquescent unit doesn’t guarantee the air will reach a certain dew point. The amount of water vapor in the air that exits the dryer is completely predicated on how much water vapor is in the air going into the dryer.

Brian Farno, MBA – CCASS
National Business Development Manager

BrianFarno@EXAIR.com
@EXAIR_BF

Critical Components of Your Compressed Air System

In any manufacturing environment, compressed air is critical to the operation of many processes. You will often hear compressed air referred to as a “4th utility” in a manufacturing environment. The makeup of a compressed air system is usually divided into two primary parts: the supply side and the demand side. The supply side consists of components before and including the pressure/flow controller. The demand side then consists of all the components after the pressure/flow controller.

The first primary component in the system is the air compressor itself. There are two main categories of air compressors: positive-displacement and dynamic. In a positive-displacement type, a given quantity of air is trapped in a compression chamber. The volume of which it occupies is mechanically reduced (squished), causing a corresponding rise in pressure. In a dynamic compressor, velocity energy is imparted to continuously flowing air by a means of impellers rotating at a very high speed. The velocity energy is then converted into pressure energy.

Still on the supply side, but installed after the compressor, are after coolers, and compressed air dryers. An after cooler is designed to cool the air down upon exiting from the compressor. During the compression, heat is generated that carries into the air supply. An after cooler uses a fan to blow ambient air across coils to lower the compressed air temperature.

When air leaves the after cooler, it is typically saturated since atmospheric air contains moisture. In higher temperatures, the air is capable of holding even more moisture. When this air is then cooled, it can no longer contain all of that moisture and is lost as condensation. The temperature at which the moisture can no longer be held is referred to as the dewpoint. Dryers are installed in the system to remove unwanted moisture from the air supply. Types of dryers available include: refrigerant dryers, desiccant dryers, and membrane dryers.

Also downstream of the compressor are filters used to remove particulate, condensate, and lubricant. Desiccant and deliquescent-type dryers require a pre-filter to protect the drying media from contamination that can quickly render it useless. A refrigerant-type dryer may not require a filter before/after, but any processes or components downstream can be impacted by contaminants in the compressed air system.

Moving on to the demand side, we have the distribution system made up of a network of compressed air piping, receiver tanks when necessary, and point of use filters/regulators. Compressed air piping is commonly available as schedule 40 steel pipe, copper pipe, and aluminum pipe. Some composite plastics are available as well, however PVC should NEVER be used for compressed air as some lubricants present in the air can act as a solvent and degrade the pipe over time.

Receiver tanks are installed in the distribution system to provide a source of compressed air close to the point of use, rather than relying on the output of the compressor. The receiver tank acts as a “battery” for the system, storing compressed air energy to be used in periods of peak demand. This helps to maintain a stable compressed air pressure. It improves the overall performance of the system and helps to prevent pressure drop.

Finally, we move on to the point-of-use. While particulate and oil removal filters may be installed at the compressor output, it is still often required to install secondary filtration immediately at the point-of-use to remove any residual debris, particulate, and oil. Receiver tanks and old piping are both notorious for delivering contaminants downstream, after the initial filters.

Regulator and filter

In any application necessitating the use of compressed air, pressure should be controlled to minimize the air consumption at the point of use. Pressure regulators are available to control the air pressure within the system and throttle the appropriate supply of air to any pneumatic device. While one advantage of a pressure regulator is certainly maintaining consistent pressure to your compressed air devices, using them to minimize your pressure can result in dramatic savings to your costs of compressed air. As pressure and flow are directly related, lowering the pressure supplied results in less compressed air usage.

EXAIR manufactures a wide variety of products utilizing this compressed air to help you with your process problems. If you’d like to discuss your compressed air system, or have an application that necessitates an Intelligent Compressed Air Product, give us a call.

Tyler Daniel, CCASS

Application Engineer
E-mail: TylerDaniel@EXAIR.com
Twitter: @EXAIR_TD

Compressor Image courtesy of Tampere Hacklab via Creative Commons License

Dew Point and Water in Compressed Air: Understanding the Effects

In systems, it is important to understand the type of medium that is being used.  For most EXAIR products, this will be compressed air.  As the air compressor draws in ambient air, it also brings in dust, contamination, and moisture into the system.  If untreated, the pneumatic system will have to contend with these foreign “invaders” that will affect the performance of your pneumatic devices.  One of the most common problems is water.

Water enters the compressed air system from the water vapor already present in the ambient air, which is referred to as the dew point or relative humidity.  When you take ambient air and compress it, the amount of “elbow room” for the water vapor decreases.  This causes the water vapor to condense and create liquid water.  It would be similar to a water-soaked sponge.   As you compress it with your hands, the sponge will not be able to hold on to the water.  Similarly, as the air is compressed, water will start to form and fall out into the compressed air system.  Water is a by-product of a compressed air system.

Visual depiction of the impact of water vapor contained amongst air particles and how this reduces available volume during compression.

The definition for determining if liquid water is present in your system is called the pressure dew point.  Dew point is the temperature at which water vapor will condense and form water droplets.  If the dew point temperature and the air temperature are equal, then the air is considered 100% saturated (water vapor will start to condense to form water droplets).  In compressed air systems, air dryers are used to reduce the dew point temperature.  This means that unless the ambient temperature falls below the dew point temperature, water vapor will not condense into a liquid state.

There are two major types of compressed air dryers; refrigerated and desiccant.  The refrigerated air dryers are the most common, and the dew point is measured at about 39oF (4oC).  So, unless the air temperature gets close to freezing, i.e., the piping system that goes outside in cold weather, water should not be present.  Desiccant air dryers can achieve dew points as low as -40oF (-40oC).  This compressed air is very dry and can be used for medical systems, food and beverage processing, and instrument air.  The reason is that bacteria cannot survive in compressed air that is that dry.  The other types are dewpoint reducing systems, which include membrane and deliquescent dryers. 

Good engineering practice calls for point of use filtration and moisture removal, such as that provided by EXAIR Filter Separators.

For most pneumatic devices, a Filter Separator with an auto-drain should be used as a minimum amount of protection.  Even with systems that have compressed air dryers as described above, they are mechanical devices.  So, failures can occur.  You should review your compressed air system to ensure that your pneumatic system, including EXAIR products, is operating at peak efficiency.  This will include your supply system, compressed air leaks, and blow-off devices. 

Moisture-laden compressed air can cause issues such as increased wear on the pneumatic tools, the formation of rust in piping and equipment, quality defects in painting processes, and frozen pipes in colder climates.  Regardless of what products you’re using at the point-of-use, a compressed air dryer is undoubtedly a critical component of the compressed air system.  Providing clean, dry air to EXAIR Products or other pneumatic devices will help to extend the life of your equipment.  If you wish to discuss more about your compressed air system or how EXAIR can provide a more efficient way to use that compressed air, an Application Engineer will be happy to assist you.

John Ball
International Application Engineer


Email: johnball@exair.com
Twitter: @EXAIR_jb